Social Media

5 Reasons Why Your Instagram Ads Aren’t Reaching Your Audience

Instagram advertising is filled with potential gains – and pitfalls. On one hand, the staple platform provides businesses of all types with a remarkable opportunity to reach engaged audiences through visually captivating content. 

On the other hand, getting your ads in front of the right people isn’t as simple as posting some pictures or whipping together a catchy reel. Plus, for small business owners juggling multiple responsibilities – where every ad dollar counts and the learning curve feels steeper – the stakes are higher.

Navigating Instagram’s complex algorithms, multiple ad formats, and ever-evolving features can be intimidating. That’s where a professional Instagram advertising agency like ours can make all the difference. With years of experience and a proven track record, we know the intricacies of Instagram’s backend inside out and are keen to help you avoid the classic traps that cause most campaigns to fail.

When it comes to mistakes that business owners commonly make when managing their Instagram ads, a handful stand out. But the good news is that once you know how to avoid them, you can set your business on a better social ads path. 

Let’s take a look at some mistakes that, let’s be honest, anyone could easily be making – and how our team at Reform Digital can help.

1. Poorly Defined Target Audience

One of the most crucial aspects of any successful advertising campaign is knowing your audience – who they are, what they like, and how they behave online. Instagram’s targeting options are plenty, allowing you to customise your audience based on age, gender, location, interests, and even behaviour. The issue is defining those factors.

Having a vague or poorly defined target audience is akin to shooting arrows in the dark; yeah, you might hit something, but it’s unlikely to be your intended target. When your target audience is undefined or too broad, Instagram’s algorithm struggles to show your ads to people who are genuinely interested in what you offer. 

Undefined target audiences result in lower engagement rates, fewer conversions, and, ultimately, wasted ad spend. For example, if you sell handmade jewellery and target everyone between the ages of 18-65, your ads might end up showing to people who have no interest in jewellery, diluting the efficacy of your campaign.

2. Creating Irrelevant Content

Surprise, it’s not enough to know who your audience is – you also need to understand what resonates with them. 

Meta is built on being social, and therefore creative content (at all) is paramount. And many businesses overlook this critical factor and end up crafting content that falls flat. Putting just anything out there isn’t enough. Even if your ad reaches the right people, if the content doesn’t strike a chord, then it’s unlikely to encourage clicks and much fewer conversions.

For example, using corporate jargon or overly complex language can alienate potential customers, especially if your target audience is young people who prefer straightforward and relatable messages. On the flip side, casual or slang language could be inappropriate if you’re targeting a more professional or an older demographic.

But it’s not just about language; visual elements matter too. An ad for a luxury product, for instance, needs to exude sophistication and exclusivity through its creative ad content and copy. A mismatch in tone, style, or imagery can send mixed signals and confuse potential customers.

Poorly aligned content will lead to lower engagement rates and poor ad performance. You’ll find your click-through rates plummeting, and the Return On Investment (ROI) on your ad spend dwindling.

3. Neglecting Ad Placements and Formats

While Instagram offers different ad placements (like Stories, Feed, and the Explore page), it doesn’t mean all are right for your campaign goals. Sometimes businesses spread their budget across all placements without considering where their audience spends most of their time and attention on the app.

Similarly, Instagram has multiple ad formats such as carousels, single-image ads, and videos. Using the wrong format for your campaign can lead to less interaction and, ultimately, lower ROI. A good example is where video ads may capture attention more effectively, they may not be ideal for quickly conveying straightforward information.

Another tip: Instagram’s built-in analytics tools can help you identify which formats and placements are most effective, giving you more bang for your advertising buck.

4. Ignoring Instagram’s Algorithm Updates

Many businesses set up their Instagram ad campaigns – and then forget about them. This is a big no-no in the world of Meta, which is constantly making updates to its algorithms. 

By not staying updated on these changes and tweaking your strategy accordingly, you’re essentially flying blind, relying on outdated tactics that may no longer be effective. Make sure to stay in the loop about any algorithm changes and adjust your ad strategies as needed. Or, if you simply can’t be bothered, outsource to a bunch of digital nerds who stay on top of it (cough cough, like us). 

5. Conducting Inadequate Testing and Optimisation

Don’t be one of those businesses that set up an Instagram ad campaign and let it run its course without revisiting it for adjustments. This lack of testing and optimisation can significantly limit the ad’s potential. Instagram’s algorithm thrives on data. The more data it has, the better it can serve your ad to the most relevant audience.

For the success of any ad campaign, let alone Instagram, it’s important to routinely check the performance metrics of your ads. Split-testing different ad elements like images, headlines, and calls-to-action (CTAs) offers valuable insights into what resonates most with your audience. 

Instagram isn’t a “set it and forget it” platform; it requires consistent monitoring and tweaking. And when you don’t have the time to conduct this yourself, that’s when a social ads agency really comes in handy, to say the least.

How Reform Digital Can Transform Your Instagram Ad Game

So, we’ve offered you some valuable insight, but it likely sounds like a lot of work, right? Pro tip: Get experts to do it all for you. 

Managing Instagram ads is an intricate and challenging task that requires expertise in multiple areas – from understanding your target audience and crafting resonant content to selecting the ideal placements and formats. Add to that the dynamic nature of Instagram’s algorithms, and you have a complex landscape that can be overwhelming.

Cue, a-hem, us. With a deep understanding of Instagram’s ecosystem, we specialise in avoiding the pitfalls that most businesses stumble into. Our team not only helps craft your creatives and set up your campaigns, but also continually monitors, tests, and optimises them. Our mission? To get you the best ROI possible by allocating your budget efficiently and tapping into data-driven insights to fine-tune your strategies.

So, if you’re looking to transform your Instagram advertising from a potential minefield into a consistent, high-ROI marketing channel, look no further than Reform Digital and contact us today.

Shubhangi is the Lead Copywriter at Reform Digital. She writes for e-commerce brands and helps them find their voice in the middle of thousands of search engine results. She is the editorial mum of the Reform team, and brings her varied background in SEO and UX copywriting to the job. She is dedicated to developing her team's skills and giving out constant TV/movie recommendations.

Before she started writing for the SERP gods, Shubhangi worked in corporate communications and dabbled in technical writing. She completed her masters in Communications and Media Studies, and holds a bachelor's degree in English and Sociology. When she isn't writing or editing, she can be found soaking up the sun with a book or a Su Doku in hand.

Reform Offices

Find us at these locations

Melbourne Office People


Level 3, 141 Osborne Street, South Yarra, VIC 3141

1300 713359


Level 1, Suite 3, Fortune House, 88 Foveaux St Surry Hills, NSW 2010

1300 713359
Melbourne Image


310 Edward St, Brisbane City, QLD 4000

1300 713359

Thanks for enquiring about

5 Reasons Why Your Instagram Ads Aren’t Reaching Your Audience

Please fill out the required fields and our team will be in touch with you shortly.